Article 5: Exhibit Disposition and Review.

Article 5: Exhibit Disposition and Review. unanimous

§ 6-501. Authorized release of exhibits.

§ 6-501. Authorized release of exhibits.

   The clerks of the various courts or the official court reporters are authorized to release, under the following conditions, any exhibit offered or received in evidence in any civil, criminal, or juvenile proceeding:

   (A) Upon request of an introducing attorney or owner, release to such introducing attorney or owner at any time during or after trial, if request is made during trial to substitute a copy and permission is granted by the court to do so.

   (B) Upon request of an introducing attorney or owner, release to such introducing attorney or owner at any time after trial or following expiration of appeal time, provided it is stipulated in writing that a copy shall be substituted, or if, in the absence of such a stipulation, the judge who tried the case, or if such judge is unavailable the current presiding judge, determines such substitution to be unnecessary.

   (C) When, in compliance with Supreme Court rules governing preparation of bills of exceptions, counsel shall substitute photographs or mechanical drawings and descriptions for any large or cumbersome exhibits where such would fairly present such exhibits to the appellate court.

unanimous

§ 6-502. Disposal of exhibits.

§ 6-502. Disposal of exhibits.

   The clerks of the various courts or the official court reporters are authorized to dispose of any exhibits or substitutes which have not been released pursuant to § 6-501 according to the applicable Records Retention and Disposition Schedules of the State Records Administrator.

unanimous

§ 6-503. Questioned ownership of exhibits.

§ 6-503. Questioned ownership of exhibits.

   Exhibits first shall be sought to be returned to the attorneys who introduced them, if possible, or to the owners, if they can be determined. Questions as to ownership of exhibits shall be submitted to the judge who tried the case, or to the presiding judge. Attorneys or owners of exhibits shall be notified to remove them; in the event of their failure to do so within 30 days, or if the attorneys or owners are not available or cannot be determined, the exhibits shall be disposed of or destroyed as ordered by the judge who tried the case, or the presiding judge.

unanimous

§ 6-504. Additional court discretion to dispose of exhibits.

§ 6-504. Additional court discretion to dispose of exhibits.

   Nothing herein shall restrict or contravene the discretion given to a court to dispose of exhibits under Neb. Rev. Stat. § 24-1004, or in requiring compliance by all parties with Neb. Rev. Stat. §§ 84-1201 to 84-1220, and nothing herein shall restrict a court from requiring retention of exhibits in any instance for a period of time in excess of that in the applicable Records Retention and Disposition Schedules of the State Records Administrator.

unanimous

§ 6-505. Neb. Rev. Stat. § 27-1301 child pornography exhibits.

§ 6-505. Neb. Rev. Stat. § 27-1301 child pornography exhibits.

   Notwithstanding the provisions of §§ 6-501 through 6-507, exhibits constituting visual depiction of sexually explicit conduct involving a child, as defined by Neb. Rev. Stat. § 27-1301 and controlled by Neb. Ct. R. § 6-1801, shall remain constantly and continuously in the care, custody, and control of the court in which the exhibit was introduced, whether or not received into evidence by such court, until it is returned to the introducing attorney or law enforcement or otherwise disposed of as ordered by that court. Exhibits under this section are not public records.

§ 6-505 adopted January 27, 2010; § 6-505 amended November 25, 2020.

unanimous

§ 6-506. Sealing of exhibits.

§ 6-506. Sealing of exhibits.

   A party to a case, or a person who has an interest in the protection of information contained in an exhibit offered and/or received in a case (interested person), may request an order or the court upon its own motion may enter a written order that seals or limits access to an exhibit subject to the provisions in § 6-507. (Appendix 1). The order shall indicate the reason(s) for sealing the record and who shall have access to the sealed record.

§ 6-506 adopted November 25, 2020.

unanimous

§ 6-507. Public review of exhibits.

§ 6-507. Public review of exhibits.

   (A) Unless nondisclosure or confidentiality is required by law or court rule, the following exhibits are presumed to be public records: (1) exhibits submitted in support of or in opposition to a motion; or (2) exhibits offered into evidence, whether or not admitted, in a court proceeding open to the public.

   (B) Procedure. A member of the public may submit to the clerk of the court a written request to inspect an exhibit or request a copy of an exhibit that is presumed to be public under § 6-507(A), even if the exhibit has previously been sealed by the court.

   (1) The clerk shall forward a copy of the request to the court; to the court reporting personnel, if custodian of the exhibit; to the parties in the case; and if applicable, to any interested person as described in § 6-506. The court may order that notice be given to any other person(s) who may be affected by the release of the exhibit. Unless the court, a party, an interested person as described in § 6-506, or other person as determined by the court objects to the release or unsealing of the exhibit within 3 business days, the custodian of such exhibit shall permit inspection or provide a copy as soon as practicable, but no more than 4 business days unless the request cannot with reasonable good faith efforts be fulfilled within 4 business days after actual receipt of the request. The requestor shall pay all reasonable costs for copies of such exhibit(s) pursuant to Neb. Rev. Stat. § 84-712.

   (2) If the court, a party, an interested person as described in § 6-506, or other person as determined by the court objects to the release or unsealing of the exhibit, the court shall hold a hearing as soon as practicable. The presumption of public status of an exhibit may be overcome if the court finds that there exists a countervailing interest in limiting public access. A countervailing interest may include, but is not limited to the following: (a) fair and orderly administration of justice; (b) protection of public safety; (c) use of exhibit for improper purposes; and/or (d) confidentiality.

   (3) The court shall first consider reasonable alternatives to sealing or restricting access to an exhibit, including delay in release of the exhibit or ordering the parties to provide a redacted version of the exhibit for public review. An agreement of the parties to seal or restrict exhibits shall not alone constitute a countervailing interest in limiting public access.

   (4) A written order restricting such public access to an exhibit shall be entered in the case and shall state with specificity the countervailing interest. If the court finds no countervailing interest exists in restricting access, then the court shall direct the release of the exhibit by the custodian for inspection or copying. (Appendix 2).

   (C) If the exhibit is nondocumentary in nature, the court, in its discretion, may place limits on access to the viewing, handling, photographing, or copying of such nondocumentary exhibits.

   (D) Unless nondisclosure or confidentiality is required by law or court rule, this rule does not prohibit a court in its discretion, with agreement from the parties and interested persons, if any, from making unsealed exhibits available to the public upon request during the course of a trial or other public proceeding.

§ 6-507 adopted November 25, 2020.

unanimous